PDA

View Full Version : The Cross


LiquidOps
Mar-19-2005, 06:19 PM
So yeah... Just playing around

Yay?

Nay?

"What were you thinking?"

Give it to me... I can take it :)

http://wanderingthroughlife.com/stf/DSC01794.jpg

Steven

David_S85
Mar-19-2005, 07:07 PM
So yeah... Just playing around

Yay?

Nay?

"What were you thinking?"

Give it to me... I can take it :)

Steven

Works for me. :thumb Like the comp. Either that background or a very dark blue. Another minimalism piece?

LiquidOps
Mar-19-2005, 07:23 PM
Works for me. :thumb Like the comp. Either that background or a very dark blue. Another minimalism piece?
I took this before the competition date... didn't even think of it..

hmmm...

more comments please :)

digital faerie
Mar-19-2005, 08:00 PM
well....since you said you could take it. :lol4

honestly, it doesn't do anything for me. does it say anything to you (religion aside)? if this were a stone cross or something with more texture.....maybe there would be something. there's a loss of detail in the cross itself. in other words, there's no story for me.

and concerning minimalism I'd say a definite no. The cross itself is a powerful symbol and by its very essence goes against everything minimalistic in the original scope of the movement.

eeek, please don't burn me at the stake for this post. :uhoh

LiquidOps
Mar-19-2005, 08:17 PM
well....since you said you could take it. :lol4

honestly, it doesn't do anything for me. does it say anything to you (religion aside)? if this were a stone cross or something with more texture.....maybe there would be something. there's a loss of detail in the cross itself. in other words, there's no story for me.

and concerning minimalism I'd say a definite no. The cross itself is a powerful symbol and by its very essence goes against everything minimalistic in the original scope of the movement.

eeek, please don't burn me at the stake for this post. :uhoh
Thank you so much for being honest. This is the kind of feedback i always want. I can't stand people who say "Ooooh... it looks great" when in reality they think to themselves... "This is horrible"

Thanks again :)

Steven

digital faerie
Mar-19-2005, 08:19 PM
Thank you so much for being honest. This is the kind of feedback i always want. I can't stand people who say "Ooooh... it looks great" when in reality they think to themselves... "This is horrible"

Thanks again :)

Steven
shew! I'm just relieved that you didn't come at me with a mob of people with pitchforks and torches. :lol4

keep at it, you never know, you might end up with a night shot that has the perfect constellation behind the cross or something.

I tried to get a shot of the moon last night and I realized that one of the dippers (I think it was one of 'em, lol) was upside down and it looked like the moon had fallen out of it. but unfortunately it didn't come out.

fish
Mar-19-2005, 08:33 PM
Thank you so much for being honest. This is the kind of feedback i always want. I can't stand people who say "Ooooh... it looks great" when in reality they think to themselves... "This is horrible"

Thanks again :)

Steven
Now that the ice has been broken...


It doesn't do anything for me either. For a couple of reasons. One, it seems like a waste of real estate on the left...it's just black...no detail, nothing. The absence of something. Secondly, well...i'm just not into crosses.

Does the image do anything for you? are you religious?

LiquidOps
Mar-19-2005, 08:40 PM
Now that the ice has been broken...


It doesn't do anything for me either. For a couple of reasons. One, it seems like a waste of real estate on the left...it's just black...no detail, nothing. The absence of something. Secondly, well...i'm just not into crosses.

Does the image do anything for you? are you religious?
I just liked the lighting on the cross. It caught my eye.

Again... like I said.. just messing around

Got to get better somehow

Steven

KeithAlanK
Mar-19-2005, 09:07 PM
Well, I get something out of it, but it's not overwhelming.
The cross doesn't need to be so bright, and maybe the black doesn't need to be so black. The contrast is just a bit much.
The empty space on the left COULD signify a lack of faith on the left....
oh well, now we're in danger of busting a rule or two.
Don't toss it.