PDA

View Full Version : cropping mad...


lynnma
Feb-22-2004, 01:40 PM
I've cropped this, can you do better?

lynnma
Feb-22-2004, 01:52 PM
and this

wxwax
Feb-22-2004, 03:13 PM
Lynn, that's a wonderful shot of the horse. Nice job! :thumb

wxwax
Feb-22-2004, 03:15 PM
I've cropped this, can you do better?

I'm at work, can't play right now. Do you have more at the top of the pic? If so, I'd have the bottom start with where the railings come in at the sides, and extend the top enough to make the road the lower third of the shot. Rule of thirds, hard at work for you.

lynnma
Feb-22-2004, 03:30 PM
I'm at work, can't play right now. Do you have more at the top of the pic? If so, I'd have the bottom start with where the railings come in at the sides, and extend the top enough to make the road the lower third of the shot. Rule of thirds, hard at work for you.Right! watch this space for my new crop.. in the meantime here is my barn crop...

lynnma
Feb-22-2004, 03:45 PM
I'm at work, can't play right now. Do you have more at the top of the pic? If so, I'd have the bottom start with where th e railings come in at the sides, and extend the top enough to make the road the lower third of the shot. Rule of thirds, hard at work for you.
2nd crop... sorry you have to work Sid:cry

lynnma
Feb-22-2004, 03:48 PM
still is'nt right... 3rd crop...HELP!!

lynnma
Feb-22-2004, 03:59 PM
Last one I promise...

lynnma
Feb-22-2004, 04:30 PM
lies all lies...

Sam
Feb-22-2004, 05:25 PM
lies all lies...

Have you been talking to my ex girlfriend?

ps: The photos look good, I especially like the barn.

I think sometimes you like a photo at first glance. Then over time the interest dies. Then there are those you keep returning to, you keep playing with them, and they grow on you. All with out benifit of alcohol. :D

wxwax
Feb-22-2004, 05:47 PM
Last one I promise...


Lynn, this is a nice one. The pattern of the houses grabs your eye at the front right of the frame, and pulls it through to the left... nice pic.

wxwax
Feb-23-2004, 12:18 AM
2nd crop... sorry you have to work Sid:cry

That's a good crop, Lynn. Sorta like this one of Patch (sorry if the levels are off, the new monitor has arrived and will be installed shortly!)

.http://wxwax.smugmug.com/photos/1329323-M.jpg

komet
Feb-23-2004, 09:33 PM
So why is cropping better than taking the original the way you want it to end up? Curious...that's all. I can see the merit with these digicams because it's so easy to take such a large pic etc. Any advice/comment?

tsiya
Feb-23-2004, 10:54 PM
So why is cropping better than taking the original the way you want it to end up? Curious...that's all. I can see the merit with these digicams because it's so easy to take such a large pic etc. Any advice/comment? It is hard to get close enough to some birds to get the result I want, even with the max optical power I have, 6X. I don't want a big picture with a small bird in the middle, The bird is what I'm after. I don't think more lens power would be the solution, I usually don't set up for shots, take them as they come, and high X power requires well anchored cameras. I also shoot small cameras, a 2.5 MP and a 4.0MP, not that I would not like a bigger set up, but part of the challenge is in getting what I want from what I have, and on My retirement income likely what I will always have. All My recent posts have been from a 2.5 MP Olympus C2500L, which will do a fine job, but there is not much room for error. Bigger files are more forgiving.
Cutting to the chase, I almost always crop, got to stretch those pixels!

wxwax
Feb-23-2004, 11:09 PM
So why is cropping better than taking the original the way you want it to end up? Curious...that's all. I can see the merit with these digicams because it's so easy to take such a large pic etc. Any advice/comment?

The quick answer is that I'm not good enough when I shoot. I use cropping to save my bad shots.

The second, slighty harder answer is that sometimes my camera can't give me the image that cropping can. Sometimes it's because the shape of the sensor isn't ideally suited to the shot, and I have to trim off the extra sides or tops/bottoms; or I can't zoom in close enough.

komet
Feb-23-2004, 11:40 PM
It is hard to get close enough to some birds to get the result I want, even with the max optical power I have, 6X. I don't want a big picture with a small bird in the middle, The bird is what I'm after. I don't think more lens power would be the solution, I usually don't set up for shots, take them as they come, and high X power requires well anchored cameras. I also shoot small cameras, a 2.5 MP and a 4.0MP, not that I would not like a bigger set up, but part of the challenge is in getting what I want from what I have, and on My retirement income likely what I will always have. All My recent posts have been from a 2.5 MP Olympus C2500L, which will do a fine job, but there is not much room for error. Bigger files are more forgiving.
Cutting to the chase, I almost always crop, got to stretch those pixels!
Thanks, you to Waxie!

pathfinder
Feb-24-2004, 04:47 AM
Have you been talking to my ex girlfriend?

ps: The photos look good, I especially like the barn.

I think sometimes you like a photo at first glance. Then over time the interest dies. Then there are those you keep returning to, you keep playing with them, and they grow on you. All with out benifit of alcohol. :DYou talking about photos ............ or something else????????????http://www.dgrin.com/images/icons/Wicked.gif