two options for numba 78

[simple]

can't pick -- which one would you guys pick over the other and why?
-thanks!

http://taylor-conboy.smugmug.com/photos/111694149-L.jpg
http://taylor-conboy.smugmug.com/photos/111694139-L.jpg

[TomaS]

Both are good - I think I prefer #1 tho. I like the surreal clouds above the sharp skyline. Clone out the lampost light on upper left, and the highlights in middle and lower right.

[truth]

Both are good - I think I prefer #1 tho. I like the surreal clouds above the sharp skyline. Clone out the lampost light on upper left, and the highlights in middle and lower right.

I agree.

[douglas]

Tough choice but i think i like 2 best, great silos

[JenGrace]

They're both very nice silhouettes. On #1, I agree with Tomas on the post. The only other thing I would change if possible would be how the hat and the skyline are melded. Some separation would make it better, but only slightly because it's already very good. :):

[Swartzy]

You might want to crop the left little light fixture out of there tho. Nice shot.

[simple]

appreciate it guys. my only main worry was that #1 was a wee bit too grainy for my liking :(

[ChrisJ]

#1! Embrace the grain! It's a cool shot, might even look better in B&W. Definitely clone out the lamp.

[nalvarez]

I actually like #2, but it could use a bit more cropping at the bottom. More original than #1

[jweatherson]

I like 2, AWESOME colors! I am a sucker for sunset's / rise, whichever they both look brilliant.
Cute pooch too :thumb but I do agree with nalcarez, crop out some of the black space!

[love]

I really like the second shot, the dog has a look of longing to fetch something out in the distant woods. Nice job!

[Awais Yaqub]

Number 1
Weldone