Challenge 78: Which one to post

[rparige]

Confused between these two photos.
#1
http://rparige.smugmug.com/photos/111283150-L.jpg

#2
http://rparige.smugmug.com/photos/111280553-L.jpg

[SloYerRoll]

I would say #1 if the plane was sharper.
#2 has my pick out of there though.

good luck in the challenge.

[photogmomma]

I would say #1 if the plane was sharper.
#2 has my pick out of there though.

good luck in the challenge.

Ditto. #2 is great, but the plane is definitely lost in it. Still a nice shot, though. I'd definitely choose it!

[nalvarez]

#1 for me - a little blurry, but captures the movement and still retains the silhouette outline.

[JenGrace]

I like 1. I don't mind that the plane is blurry cos it catches a sense of motion for me. :):

[Osprey]

The plane is the one. I conveys something more then 2nd shot to me. nice work.

[rparige]

Thank you for the feedback
How about this one?
http://rparige.smugmug.com/photos/111283671-L.jpg

[Yuri Pautov]

I like #1
Yuri

[nalvarez]

still #1 for me - much more dramatic.

[SloYerRoll]

I'm starting to dig #3 now.

I would do some pp work on 3 to make the shot more dramatic and visually appealing.

If your a photo "purist" though and don't do pp. My vote is still for one then.

[jweatherson]

I personally like 3, I really think that's a brilliant shot, number 1 looks too blurry and takes away from it, where as 3 is crisp and there's no doubt in your mind it's a silouette!

[ChrisJ]

To me, #2 is still my favorite (even though I wish the plane was more visible). The sky in #1 is fantastic, but the airplane blur takes away from the shot...