Duke St Bridge rework

[gubbs]

The local council have asked people to submit photographs of the town for an exhibition, I was considering this one, what do you think, have I gone too far with ps?
http://Gubbs.smugmug.com/photos/9756364-L.jpg

[gubbs]

This is the slightly adjusted original

http://Gubbs.smugmug.com/photos/6924668-L.jpg

[lynnma]

This is the slightly adjusted original

I like the color version Gubbs.. the black and white confused me a bit when I first opned it.. .
Lynn

[wxwax]

I think I agree with Lynn, Gubbs. I prefer the color to the B&W, easier to tell which way is up. BTW, this touches on one of my problems with reflections: assuming you can't fit the whole thing in the frame, what should be dominant in the composition - the object itself or its reflection?