What would you do with this?

[chas6000]

I like this photo - the clouds, the mountains and island in the background. but it lacks much breadth of color. and it just doesnt DO it for me. but I dont know what I feel its missing... any ideas? suggestions? feel free to play!
ciao
http://img294.imageshack.us/img294/2640/img6165psp9zr.jpg

[gefillmore]

basically all you have here is blue, but a very nice photo--

if color doesn't do it for you, go to bw, or bw and tone-

here I converted it to bw and toned with cyan-

http://gefillmore.smugmug.com/photos/61924865-L.jpg

[gefillmore]

by the way-

welcome to the forum-

not that it's done much, but if you're needing or wanting help and you're not getting any response, just reply to it and 'bump' it-

maybe this will get you some more ideas because if there's two that would do what I did to the pic there's twenty that have ten other ideas-

george

[dandill]

... any ideas? suggestions? feel free to play! What about cropping to horizontal aspect? say with clouds possibly extnding to the top of the frame, and also eliminating much of the water on the bottom, perhaps by cropping almost to the bow of the boat?

[edgework]

I like this photo - the clouds, the mountains and island in the background. but it lacks much breadth of color. and it just doesnt DO it for me. but I dont know what I feel its missing... any ideas? suggestions? feel free to play!

Nothing dramatic; some color enhancement in lab, after using the Red plate as a luminosity overlay. Sharpened with High Pass filter.

http://edgework.tripod.com/samples/boat.jpg

[wholenewlight]

Nothing dramatic; some color enhancement in lab, after using the Red plate as a luminosity overlay. Sharpened with High Pass filter.



oooh, too much "enhancement", me thinks.:uhoh

[gefillmore]

well, I'll admit that I've been accused, rightfully so, of cooking my color well done-

maybe that's why I so much like what edgework has done to this photo-

maybe the sky's a bit much, but I like the way the green has come out on the mountains, hills, whatever-

I think it's made a dramatic difference in the pic, but, no expert I-

george

[wholenewlight]

Here's my take: Lab steepen a & b, slight adjustment to lightness channel, USM to lightness channel only, back to RGB, gradient to upper sky, crop.

http://cs-pics.smugmug.com/photos/61959577-L.jpg

Hard to add a diversity in colors - ie. green in the mountains - with global changes. More important in my opinion, to keep the white boat neutral. I didn't do any masking but you could do that to bring out mountains withour changing other areas.

[chas6000]

Thanks to all for the great ideas and efforts!

chas

[JohnR]

Well, I don't want to make anyone jealous with my PS skillz but I thought I would show you my handiwork. :thumb

http://www.orangeinsider.org///shark.jpg

[MarkR]

I think the two LAB attempts are a little too overboard-- bordering on radioactive-- for my taste.

Here's my attempt using nothing but curves. I tried to neutralize the clouds somewhat-- too much green and blue in the clouds, and way too much blue in the mountains in the background. The boat's pretty blown out though. :dunno

[gefillmore]

Well, I don't want to make anyone jealous with my PS skillz but I thought I would show you my handiwork. :thumb

http://www.orangeinsider.org///shark.jpg

johnr-

I'm having a hard time following what you did here-

could you go over this step-by-step?-

thanks
george

[ratcheer]

I'm kind of a newbie, but I like the way mine came out. First I adjusted the black point, then I applied a contrast overlay mask. Then I decomposed to LAB and steepened the curves a little and converted back. There's still a lot of blue, but I expect it was pretty blue in real life.

Tim

[adriano]

RGB + LAB curves. the boat was ruined, and maybe I've exagerated on the warm yellow for clouds + Island but I just can't stand blue casts :P


BTW, the dgrin.com server is so slowwwwwwww :(

[chas6000]

Thanks for great ideas and treatments. trying them out is a great way to learn.

thanks to all and thanks for a good forum!

[chas6000]

thanks to all for the ideas and the inspiration! good forum!

http://img45.imageshack.us/img45/6963/img6165psp67tc.jpg

[CookieS]

I want to see the shark added to the photo, I like that shot ;) , but If you are gonna show off,,Finish it . :lust

[Grace]

I like the image and content as well as focus and DOF. Perhaps there is a bit much cyan but the sky is blue and the refelction of that blue should be in the water as well (and it is in your original). Even murky water looks blue on a good day. My suggestions would be to flip the image horizontally since we read left to right, you have leading lines in the clouds and mountains but as is they lead us right out of the image. Allow them to work for you leading the viewer right to the boat. I would also crop off a bit of the water. The water is nice but not dramatic so you don't need much and my preference is the more dramatic composition with the lower horizon. Pretty shot though, makes me want to be there.


Grace

[yukiyubi]

This is mine. It's colorful. I like colors.
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f94/yukiyubi422/img6165psp9zr2.jpg
Played in Levels & Curves.

[LittleLew]

I'm not sure that its the colors that are the problem here as much as the composition. THere isn't much dynamism in the image. The deck of the boat is almost at the shoreline level etc.

Maybe a more unbalanced compostion would add a little. Any comments?

http://img57.imageshack.us/img57/5024/boat3eu.jpg

[markos]

http://majamarko.smugmug.com/photos/64517878-O.jpg

Some velvia vision plugin effect + selective color in PS.

The only problem with this photo as I see is burnt out white sail boat.

Cheers,
Marko

[fat bloke]

Here's my take: Lab steepen a & b, slight adjustment to lightness channel, USM to lightness channel only, back to RGB, gradient to upper sky, crop.

http://cs-pics.smugmug.com/photos/61959577-L.jpg

Hard to add a diversity in colors - ie. green in the mountains - with global changes. More important in my opinion, to keep the white boat neutral. I didn't do any masking but you could do that to bring out mountains withour changing other areas.

I think that a steepening of just the a channel in Lab mode would increase separation and saturation in the greens without affecting the blues at all.