what do you think?

[uberphotos]

I would like some overall critiques of the following two pictures... everything from composition to lighting. . thanks.

http://uberphotos.smugmug.com/photos/34017210-L.jpg

[Andy]

what do i think? i think you should read the rulez (http://www.dgrin.com/showthread.php?t=13428) and pic one of these two photos for us to critique :lol3

thanks uber

[uberphotos]

what do i think? i think you should read the rulez (http://www.dgrin.com/showthread.php?t=13428) and pic one of these two photos for us to critique :lol3

thanks uberopps... I'm sorry I suck... I did read the rules... but I've never been good at following directions. . I'll do better next time... I promise... but now that we all know how much I suck... any comments on the photos...:huh

[Andy]

opps... I'm sorry I suck... I did read the rules... but I've never been good at following directions. . I'll do better next time... I promise... but now that we all know how much I suck... any comments on the photos...:huh

my comment is that rulez are rulez.... i deleted one of your pics. you may post another next week :deal

[Andy]

i like the composition, it's fairly classic - the pic has some nice drama to it, and there's good tonal range. it's a lovely shot and i can't think of any improvement. bet it would look good in print :thumb

[adrian_k]

I think Andy's description of 'drama' is very apt.

However, I see some nasty haloing down the RHS of the trunk (unsharpen mask overkill???)


i like the composition, it's fairly classic - the pic has some nice drama to it, and there's good tonal range. it's a lovely shot and i can't think of any improvement. bet it would look good in print :thumb

[uberphotos]

I think Andy's description of 'drama' is very apt.

However, I see some nasty haloing down the RHS of the trunk (unsharpen mask overkill???)I see what you're saying...I may have gone a little crazy...thanks