Macro equipment help

[BenRG]

So I'd like to shoot macro but lack the necessary equipment. I have four options that I know of, I can a) buy a macro lens b) get an extension tube c) get a close-up lens d) reverse macro (if I'm missing any let me know). I'm wondering which will the best option for the lowest price.

I'm using a Canon 20D with an 18-55mm lens (currently my only lens).

I found a close-up lens set (http://amzn.com/B000SSQYJA) on Amazon for pretty cheap (seems to be the least expensive option) but I doubt how well it will perform. I could probably afford a fairly good macro lens but I'd like to spend as little as possible.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

[catspaw]

extension tubes are the cheapest way to start, using the lenses you have. So is a ring to reverse lenses, depending on what you have already. If you have to buy a lens just to reverse it, it's not worth the $$.

[Lord Vetinari]

The best option would be to get a macro a lens for ease of use and image quality.
The cheapest best quality option would be to get a set of extension tubes (preferably with electronic contacts - eg Kenko) - you would beed to make sure they are EF-S compatable ones.
Add on dioptre sets can work well but I would stay away from the cheapo ones- they suffer from chromatic aberration. You can get fairly cheap ones made by Raynox or Opteka which are better multi element ones.

You can reverse the kit lens onto the camera body with a body reversing adapter and get pretty good macros- the disadvantage of this is you lose aperture control and have to set the aperture with the lens mounted normally first and then remove the lens whilst pressing the DOF preview button. This gives a rather dim viewfinder.

Brian V.

[BenRG]

Thanks for the responses. If I'm going to go with an extension tube, which size should I be looking at? (to work best with my lens for macro shots that is)

Should I just get this set (http://amzn.com/B000U8Y88M)?

[Skippy]

Thanks for the responses. If I'm going to go with an extension tube, which size should I be looking at? (to work best with my lens for macro shots that is)

Should I just get this set (http://amzn.com/B000U8Y88M)?

Hi there Ben,

Yes the Kenkos are great, I have a set of those, and you will not regret buying them.

They are not only useful for Macro on smaller lenses, but you can use them on much larger lenses such as a 70mm-200mm.

You can use those Kenko's in any combination,
on their own individually or in multiples :D

They will allow you to AUTO Focus to an extent, but you are better off Manually focusing as the AUTO Focus will being to hunt.
You can then move to Manual and achieve focus.

Good luck Ben :thumb .... Skippy :D
.

[the supervillain]

that kenko set is probably the best bang for your buck, they will retain all the auto functions of your camera like lordv said.

what is your budget?, you can get pretty decently priced macro lens' from third party manufacturers like tamron or sigma

the tamron 90mm macro has received very good reviews and is pretty cheap (on amazon at least, $450 us)

the advantage here is quality, working distance (with the extension tubes you may have to get pretty close to the subject, while the 90mm macro will allow you to focus a bit farther away)

whatever you decide on, welcome to the wonderful of macro photography! its addicting :)

[BenRG]

I think I'm going to go with the Kenko set, the macro lenses are a bit pricey. Thanks for the help everyone. :D

[ian408]

Bum your dad's 70-200 and use that with the Kenko :wink

[DavidTO]

Bum your dad's 70-200 and use that with the Kenko :wink


Dad may be bumming the Kenko's right back! :D I've had my eye on those! :deal

[ian408]

Dad may be bumming the Kenko's right back! :D I've had my eye on those! :deal
As you should :D