#27 First Time Feedback Please

[cgmcdonald]

In no particular order


http://charlesmcdonald.smugmug.com/photos/560318741_qtuNn-M.jpg
#1

http://charlesmcdonald.smugmug.com/photos/560318459_8PuWz-M.jpg
#2

http://charlesmcdonald.smugmug.com/photos/560319260_f5qHB-M.jpg
#3

http://www.charlesmcdonaldphotography.com/photos/560325224_wfujy-M.jpg
#4

Any feedback would be wonderful and much appreciated!

[Katmitchell]

Hello Charles,

Welcome to DG.. I like that name Charles... That is my brother's name.. always did favor it..:D

I like the composition and the exposure best on #3.

#1 is ok too........

However, I am curious as to what a "closer" crop would look like on #2, that fence adds character to the shot.

nice work..:thumb

Kat

[karlabbott]

Really like the composition on #4, though I don't really get the feel of the theme from #4. However, I do get a strong sense of the theme with #1. I only wish there was a bit of a background in #1 or something to give a little bit more context to the image. #2 gives the context, but its composition just doesn't seem as strong to me.

Karl