CH 38 - Please help me choose....

[NeilyB]

I've been looking for a shot to be able to enter this time round...

Please offer feedback / advice as you see fit on the attached...

One Firework..
http://proudto.servepics.com/Dgrin/Firework2.jpg

EXIF:
Date/Time: 2005:05:08 22:12:00
Shutter speed: 0.707106 sec
Aperture: 8
Exposure mode: Manual
ISO: 100
Focal length: 28mm

One colour as far as the eye can see....
http://proudto.servepics.com/Dgrin/One%20Colour.jpg

EXIF:
Date/Time: 2005:05:08 11:21:20
Shutter speed: 1/2000 sec
Aperture: 3.5
ISO: 100
Focal length: 15mm

One Old Tree
http://proudto.servepics.com/Dgrin/One%20Tree.jpg

EXIF:
Date/Time: 2005:05:04 20:22:44
Shutter speed: 1/45 sec
Aperture: 5.6
ISO: 200
Focal length: 70mm

One tree at sunset...
http://proudto.servepics.com/Dgrin/Tree.jpg

EXIF:
Date/Time: 2005:05:04 20:09:44
Shutter speed: 1/60 sec
Aperture: 19
ISO: 200
Focal length: 400mm

One photographer looking for his dog....
http://proudto.servepics.com/Dgrin/One.jpg

EXIF:
Date/Time: 2005:05:04 20:29:37
Shutter speed: 1/30 sec
Aperture: 2.8
ISO: 200
Focal length: 200mm


Thanks in advance

NeilyB

[lukiedukie]

i like the old tree

[GREAPER]

If I had to choose one, I would say the old tree as well, but I dont think it's got what it takes to win. It's nice enough but it doesn't GRAB me the way it will need to to win.

The sunset tree is nice, but the tree is soft.

I like the photographer, but it is a little centered, and I think a little tight to get the "One" feeling.

The yellow field is nice, but it says predominant color to me more than it does "one" Only the title makes it remotly fit the theme to me.

The fireworks shot is nice, but It doesnt say "one" to me either, dont know why, just doesn't. The shot would work better with something in the shot to establish setting.

Now that I said all of that with the intent to help, let me point out that I have never placed in the top 10 in a challenge and dont really know what it takes to win, other than knowing that the winners are darn good.