I can't decide for #8

[Grly]

Help!

I entered my original photo at the start of the contest which is this:

Polished... off!
http://grly.smugmug.com/photos/373829636_khsoX-L-1.jpg

Now I am not so sure...

I have some others that I recently took. Which one should I use?

http://grly.smugmug.com/photos/376709947_efxDx-L.jpg


http://grly.smugmug.com/photos/376728661_ZC7We-L.jpg


http://grly.smugmug.com/photos/376706243_dtitm-L.jpg


http://grly.smugmug.com/photos/375813968_p6988-L.jpg

Thanks in advance for any help!

[Pilznr]

I personally like the original Polished Off toilet paper idea. The other photos are good, but I like the concept of the original.

[idiom]

I personally like the original Polished Off toilet paper idea. The other photos are good, but I like the concept of the original.

She already knows this, but i completely concur with pilznr. It's the interpretation of the topics that I really enjoyed about the original post. Not only that, but it tells a story! :D

[divamum]

Every time I scan the entry thread your toilet-paper holder makes me smile - keep it! It goes beyond "well lit object" and is a witty interpretation of the theme. Your other pictures are lovely images, but not as imaginative as your first idea, IMO!

Just Da N00b's 2c :)

[Grly]

Ok thanks everyone! I will keep it as is then :)